Supplier quote comparison: every quote in the same columns

Quotes line up when the RFQ (request for quote) sets the quantities, separates tooling and gives every supplier one response format. Allied Mile writes RFQs that way, then lines up every response: price, tooling, lead time, MOQ (minimum order quantity), validity and terms.

What does a supplier quote comparison look like?

A quote comparison puts every supplier's answer in the same columns at the same quantities, with tooling on its own line and anything a quote leaves out written down rather than guessed. Here's an example: three machine shops quote HSG-3305 Rev A, a 6061-T6 aluminum housing, at 100, 500 and 2,000 pieces. The RFQ asked for Type II anodize, material certs and an FAI (first-article inspection) report.

SupplierUnit price 100 / 500 / 2,000 pcsToolingLead timeValidityIncludes
Supplier A$31.40 / $24.90 / $19.80$850 fixture; you own it5 weeks30 days from quoteAnodize, material certs; FAI not quoted
Supplier BNot quoted (MOQ 250) / $22.10 / $17.95In piece price; stays with B6 weeks60 days from quoteMaterial certs; anodize "by others"; FAI not quoted
Supplier C$33.20 / $25.60 / $18.40$1,400 fixtures and inspection program; yours once paid4 weeks30 days from quoteAnodize, material certs, FAI report

Supplier B has the cheapest unit price at both quantities it quoted. It also leaves out the anodize, keeps the fixture and can't fill the 100-piece break; the totals table further down, which adds MOQ and terms, shows what that does to the comparison. The RFQ fields that let quotes line up like this are on the manufacturing RFQ checklist.

Download

What you send and what you get back

You send

  • The PDF drawing and a STEP or native CAD file at the revision you want quoted
  • The quantities to quote and your expected annual volume
  • Material, finish, inspection and certification requirements
  • Dates, delivery location, and any suppliers to include or avoid

You get back

  • An RFQ package that asks every supplier for the same quantities and the same response format
  • A quote comparison at the same quantities: unit price per break, tooling and who owns it, lead time, MOQ, validity, terms, and what each quote includes or excludes
  • Every exception a supplier took, and its engineering questions, routed to you

How does a quote comparison come together?

  1. You send the part and the quantities

    Send the drawing and revision, a STEP or native CAD file, the quantities to quote, dates, delivery location and any suppliers to include. We sign your NDA (non-disclosure agreement) on request before you send drawings. If the part is one line of a larger bill of materials (BOM), start with BOM sourcing, where every line is sorted first.

  2. You approve the supplier list

    We propose manufacturers in the U.S., Canada and Mexico that make this kind of part; how we find and vet manufacturers has its own page. Add a shop you already use, strike one you'd rather not ask. No RFQ goes out before you approve the list.

  3. We send the RFQ package

    Every supplier gets the same package: drawing and revision, quantities, material, finish, inspection requirements, dates and the response format. A shop's engineering questions about your drawing come to you to answer.

  4. We collect and line up the responses

    We follow up on late and incomplete responses, then put each quote into the same columns at the quantities the RFQ set, with every exception written down next to the number it affects.

  5. You choose and place the PO

    Every quote names its supplier. You choose, contact the supplier directly and place the PO (purchase order).

What goes into an RFQ package so quotes line up?

An RFQ package tells every supplier the same thing and asks for the answer in the same shape. Seven fields decide whether the quotes can be compared at all. Dates, delivery location, packaging, NDA status and the response deadline round out the package; the full list, with a template, is on the manufacturing RFQ checklist. The fields that move a machined part's price most are on production CNC machining sourcing.

  • Part number and revision, with the PDF drawing and STEP model at that revision. A quote on the wrong revision isn't a quote.
  • Material spec and grade, and whether a substitute is acceptable.
  • Finish spec, and that finish is to be quoted in. A separate finisher often does this work, so some shops leave it out unless asked.
  • The inspection and certs you require: FAI, a CoC (certificate of conformance), material certs.
  • The same quantity breaks for every supplier, and your expected annual volume.
  • Tooling as a separate line, with who owns it. If a quote says NRE (non-recurring engineering), that's tooling/NRE and belongs on this line.
  • A response format: unit price per break, tooling, lead time and its basis, MOQ, validity, payment and shipping terms, country of manufacture, and how to mark an exception or a no-quote.

How do you line up quotes that arrive in different formats?

Normalizing quotes means holding every response to the quantities and format the RFQ asked for, and writing down each place a quote departs from them. Five steps do most of the work.

  • Same quantities. Every price is shown at the breaks the RFQ set. A quote at another quantity is marked as an exception and kept on the sheet with its quantity next to it, so it isn't read as a requested break. We ask that shop for the breaks the RFQ named; if it won't go below its MOQ, that break reads 'not quoted'.
  • Tooling separated. Fixtures, programs and gauges go on their own line with the owner named. A piece price with tooling built in is noted, because that tooling stays with the supplier and you would pay for it again if you ever moved the part to a second source.
  • Exclusions noted. Anything the RFQ asked for and the quote leaves out, such as finish, material certs, an FAI report or packaging, is written in the Includes column, in the shop's own words where it gave any. We don't add an estimate to make a total look complete.
  • Validity captured. Each quote's validity is recorded, so you can see which prices need re-confirming if the decision slips.
  • Terms aligned. Payment terms, MOQ, the lead-time basis (from PO, or from first-article approval) and shipping terms are written the same way for every supplier, so 'Net 30' next to '50% deposit' is a real difference and not a formatting one.

Which quote is cheapest at each quantity?

It changes with quantity. Of the two quotes that can be totaled, Supplier A is cheapest at 100 and 500 pieces and Supplier C at 2,000, where its lower unit price repays the larger tooling charge. Here's the same example with tooling added, as one order at each quantity.

Supplier B's totals stay open until anodize is priced: ask B to re-quote with finish, or get a finisher's price and add it. B overtakes A at 500 pieces only if anodize comes in under about $4.50 a piece, and overtakes C at 2,000 only under about $1.15 a piece.

Example: the same three quotes with tooling added, one order at each quantity
SupplierTotal at 100 pcsTotal at 500 pcsTotal at 2,000 pcsMOQTerms
Supplier A$3,990$13,300$40,450100Net 30
Supplier BNot quoted$11,050 + anodize$35,900 + anodize250Net 30
Supplier C$4,720$14,200$38,20010050% deposit on tooling; Net 30 on parts
  • Total = unit price × quantity + tooling. Supplier B's tooling is inside its piece price, so none is added.

What doesn't a quote comparison tell you?

A quote comparison shows what each supplier committed to on paper, not how it will perform. On-time delivery, what a shop does when a revision changes, and whether parts arrive to drawing come from your own qualification, such as an FAI on the first lot, and from the first orders you place.

Requirements and limitations

  • Suppliers set their own prices, MOQs and validity, and can decline a quantity or the whole RFQ, so a break can come back with fewer quotes than requested.
  • A quote on a different revision, quantity or finish than the RFQ asked for is flagged, not adjusted. Only a re-quote from that supplier makes it comparable.

Questions buyers ask

Can my current supplier be on the sheet?
Yes. Add it when you approve the supplier list. It gets the same RFQ package as the others, and its quote goes into the same columns, so you can see where its price, tooling and terms sit against the alternatives.
Why not just take the cheapest unit price?
Because at each quantity the cheapest total depends on tooling, exclusions and MOQ as much as on unit price. In the example, the cheapest unit price belongs to the one quote that can't be totaled yet, and the cheapest total moves from Supplier A to Supplier C between 500 and 2,000 pieces.
What if a quote expires before we decide?
Contact the supplier for a fresh price; it may hold, or it may move with material costs. A 60-day validity, like Supplier B's in the example, gives you more room than a 30-day one, which is why the RFQ asks for the validity you need.

Have quotes that don't line up?