Manufacturing marketplace vs direct sourcing: which route fits your parts?
A marketplace fits a few parts priced from a CAD file. Direct shops fit parts you'll reorder from a supplier you know. Allied Mile works the direct way: we run the requests for quote, you approve the supplier list and place the purchase orders.
The difference
A manufacturing marketplace prices a part from its CAD (computer-aided design) file, usually in minutes, then places the work with a shop in its network; you buy from the marketplace, which chooses the shop. Direct sourcing sends a request for quote (RFQ) for each made-to-print line of your bill of materials (BOM) to shops that make that kind of part; each quote names its shop, and you place the purchase order (PO) with the one you choose. Fathom and Jiga sit between the two: Fathom is a contract manufacturer that quotes through its own engineers, and Jiga routes RFQs to shops you can talk to while staying the supplier of record. The direct route with help is the work on our BOM sourcing page.
Where marketplaces, Fathom, Jiga and direct shops differ
| Manufacturing marketplaces | Fathom | Jiga | Direct with shops | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who you deal with | The marketplace, which picks the shop. Protolabs Network: 'We select the best manufacturer for your order'. The shop is its supplier, not yours. | Fathom, as the manufacturer: 'Contract Manufacturing Designed Around You'. | Jiga, as the 'Single supplier of record', with 'Direct comms with vetted suppliers'. | The shop. With us, we run the RFQs and collect the quotes; you contact the shop and place the PO. |
| BOM handling | One CAD file per part on all three ('Upload your CAD file', Fictiv). Whole-BOM intake not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026); Fictiv offers analyses on removing 'costs from your bill of materials'. | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). The site mentions 'complex assemblies' and 'Assembly & Finishing'. | Whole BOM: 'Multi-level BOMs, assembly grouping, batch scheduling'. | Whole or partial BOM. Yourself: sort the lines and write an RFQ per made-to-print line. With us: we review and sort every line and send RFQs for the made-to-print ones. |
| Supplier identity disclosed | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026), for all three. | Fathom is the manufacturer and names seven U.S. sites plus a 'Global Network'. Which site makes your part: not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | Yes: 'qualified machine shops you can see, talk to and audit'. | Yes. You are dealing with the shop. With us, every quote names its supplier. |
| Quoting method | Software prices the CAD file: 'Quote Custom Parts in Seconds' (Xometry); 'instant pricing and DFM feedback' (Fictiv; DFM is design for manufacturability); CAD compared by 'machine learning algorithms' to past parts (Protolabs Network). | Request a quote: 'Every quote is reviewed by an experienced engineer'. | RFQ to shops: 'RFQs routed on data and judgment'. | RFQ to shops. Each shop prices your drawing, revision, quantities, material and finish. With us, we set the quantities and format so the responses line up. |
| Minimum order quantity (MOQ) | Xometry: 'no minimums required'. Fictiv: 'low minimum order quantities' for injection molding, not quantified. Protolabs Network: '1 to 1M parts' for injection molding; otherwise not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | 'We specialize in low-volume/high-mix projects.' MOQ figures not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | 'No production commitment. Start with one part.' | Set by each shop and asked for in every RFQ. Production shops often set one; a quote comparison shows it per quote. |
| Certifications offered | Xometry lists ISO 9001:2015, ISO 13485:2016, AS9100D, IATF 16949:2016, ITAR, CMMC Level 2 and JCP. Fictiv's footer links to an 'ISO 9001:2015 Certificate'. Protolabs Network shows ISO 9001:2015 and AS9100D. | ISO 9001:2015, ISO 13485:2016, AS9100D, ITAR, NIST 800-171 and a 'Made in the USA' badge, with the footnote 'Certifications vary by location'. | AS9100 Rev D, ISO 9001:2015, ISO 13485, IATF 16949, ITAR & JCP and NADCAP, described as held by shops in its network. | Whatever each shop holds; you ask for the certificate in the RFQ. With us, certificates are reviewed when you require them. |
| Tooling ownership | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026), for all three. | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | Agreed in your PO with the shop that builds the tool. Ask for tooling as a separate quote line so ownership is explicit. |
| Where parts are made | Xometry: 'A U.S. and global network', countries not named. Fictiv: U.S., China, India, Japan and Mexico. Protolabs Network: facilities in the Netherlands, Texas, the United Kingdom, India and China. | Seven U.S. sites named (Austin, Denver, Elk Grove, Ithaca, Milwaukee, Minneapolis, Newark) plus a 'Global Network'. | Its shops are 'across the US and allied countries'; countries not named. | Wherever the shops you ask are. With us, suppliers in the U.S., Canada and Mexico. |
| Fees model | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). You order at the quoted part price. | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | Not stated on vendor site (checked Nov 16, 2026). | Yourself: your team's time. With us: Not published. |
- Xometry, Fictiv and Protolabs Network (formerly Hubs) share a column because their homepages describe the same model: one CAD file per part, a price generated by software, and a shop chosen from the marketplace's network (Xometry: 'A U.S. and global network of certified suppliers'; Fictiv 'manages manufacturing through our global network'; Protolabs Network: 'hundreds of manufacturers in our network'). Where one says something the others don't, the cell names it.
- Every cell for a named company quotes or paraphrases that company's homepage as read on Nov 16, 2026; the pages are listed under Sources. Sites change, and 'not stated' means the homepage did not say, not that the company does not offer it. Ask them.
- The direct column describes dealing with shops yourself or through us: manufacturers in the U.S., Canada and Mexico, vetted for process and material fit, volume-range fit, and certificates reviewed when you require them. You see and approve the supplier list before any RFQ goes out.
- Supplier identity disclosed: Jiga's own homepage lists 'Who actually made our last order? My QE is asking for the supplier's cert' (QE: quality engineer) as a problem with undisclosed shops. It is a fair question to put to any route.
- Certifications offered: A listed certificate may be the marketplace's or network's, not the shop's. Ask whose certificate covers your part and who signs the CoC (certificate of conformance). ITAR (International Traffic in Arms Regulations) registration matters when your drawings are defense-controlled.
When each option fits
Manufacturing marketplaces
- The CAD file carries the requirement, with little on the drawing (tolerances, finish, inspection) that needs a person to price, and you need the parts priced today.
- It's a prototype or a one-off, and you don't expect to reorder it.
- You don't need to know which shop made the part, or to visit it.
Fathom
- You want one U.S. contract manufacturer to quote, make and finish or assemble the parts.
- Your work is low-volume and high-mix, and you'd rather have an engineer review each quote than a price in seconds.
- A regulated program needs the maker's own certificate; check which Fathom site holds it, since its footnote says 'Certifications vary by location'.
Jiga
- You want to talk to the shop but hold one PO with one company.
- You have a multi-level BOM and want it grouped and scheduled together.
- You want to start with one part and grow without a production commitment.
Direct with shops
- You'll reorder the part, and you want the relationship, the tooling and the certificates between you and the shop.
- Your BOM has many made-to-print lines across processes, and you want each quoted by the kind of shop that makes it.
- You have, or want, a second source, so you need to know who makes what.
- You don't have hours for RFQs, and would rather a sourcing partner found and vetted the shops and ran the RFQs to a list you approve.
Which route fits one shaft at 25 pieces and at 1,000 a year?
At 25 pieces, a marketplace. At 1,000 a year, direct RFQs to turning shops, or Fathom or Jiga if you want one company on the PO. Here's the example: SHFT-0310 Rev A, a ground shaft in 416 stainless, the same part quoted on our production-run CNC sourcing page. Say you need 25 pieces for a prototype build now and expect 1,000 a year once the product ships.
For the 25, you send the STEP file through the site, get a price in minutes and order. The ground finish and tolerance notes on the drawing may need a manual review, so check that the quote names the finish and the tolerance it will hold. The site may not tell you which shop turned the shafts, and for a prototype build that rarely matters.
At 1,000 pieces a year, the questions change. Who holds the material certificate for the 416 bar? Who signs the CoC? If the grinding is subcontracted, who is responsible when a lot is out of tolerance? Can you visit, audit or second-source the shop? A direct RFQ to two or three turning shops answers these by naming the shop.
Price alone won't settle it. A marketplace's price at 1,000 may be competitive; what you give up is knowing who makes the part and the terms you negotiate directly: lead time, MOQ, payment terms, a price break at 5,000. For a hardware startup, the move from marketplace to direct shops usually comes with the first production order; see sourcing for hardware startups.
| Question | 25 pcs (prototype build) | 1,000 pcs a year (production) |
|---|---|---|
| Likely route | Marketplace, or Jiga for a single part | Direct RFQ to turning shops, yourself or with us; Fathom or Jiga if you want one company on the PO |
| What you send | STEP file; drawing if the site accepts one | Drawing with revision, STEP file, quantities and breaks, material spec, finish, inspection requirements |
| What you learn about the maker | The marketplace's name. Whether you learn the shop's: not stated on the three sites. | The shop's name, site, certificates and capacity, before you place the PO |
| Tooling and fixtures | Rarely a question at 25 pieces | Quoted as a separate line; ownership set in your PO |
| What to ask about | Does the price include the ground finish? Which tolerance will be held? | MOQ, lead time, payment terms, material certs, CoC, who does the grinding, price at 5,000 |
What you give up with each route
Each route trades something for something else. None removes the work of specifying the part.
- Marketplace: you give up choosing the shop and, unless the site says otherwise, knowing who it is. Terms and MOQs are set by the marketplace, not negotiated with the shop, and none of the three homepages says who owns tooling you pay for, so ask before ordering a mold. You gain a price in minutes and one order to place. Before a production order, read what each process needs in the drawing package on our custom parts sourcing page, because a CAD file alone rarely carries it.
- Fathom: you give up comparing several shops' prices, since one company quotes. You gain an engineer's review of each quote and one manufacturer accountable for the parts.
- Jiga: you gain the shop's name and a direct conversation; the PO, terms and any dispute still run through Jiga, so read its terms on tooling and reorders.
- Direct with shops: you give up the hours it takes to find shops, write RFQ packages and line up quotes that arrive in different formats. Doing it with us moves the finding, vetting and RFQ work to us; approving the supplier list, answering suppliers' engineering questions, choosing a shop and placing the PO stay with you.
- On every route, suppliers set their own prices, lead times and MOQs, and not every RFQ draws a response at very low quantities. Our vetting narrows the field; it doesn't replace your own qualification, such as an FAI (first-article inspection).
Questions to ask before a production order
Put these to a marketplace, to Fathom or Jiga, and to any sourcing partner, including us. A route that answers them plainly can carry production work; if one won't answer a question, note that in your comparison.
- Will I know which shop makes this part, and will the same shop make the reorders?
- Whose certificate covers my part, yours or the shop's? Who signs the CoC and who supplies material certs?
- Who owns the mold or fixtures I pay for, and can I move them to another shop later?
- Was this price generated from the CAD file alone, or did someone read the drawing notes?
- If the shop has a question about my drawing, who answers it, and do I hear about it?
- What is the price and lead time at 1,000 and at 5,000 pieces, and is there an MOQ at production volume?
- If a lot fails inspection, who is responsible for the rework or replacement, and on what timeline?
Questions buyers ask
- Is Allied Mile a marketplace?
- No. We don't price parts or make them. We review your BOM, find and vet shops in the U.S., Canada and Mexico, and run RFQs to the supplier list you approve. Every quote names its shop, and you contact that shop and place the PO.
- Can I use a marketplace for prototypes and go direct for production?
- Yes, and the handover is simpler than it sounds. The drawing, revision and STEP file you used for prototypes are the core of a production RFQ package; add quantities with price breaks, finish and inspection requirements, and the shops can quote.
- Is Fathom a marketplace?
- Its homepage calls it a contract manufacturer with seven named U.S. sites and a 'Global Network'. We include it because buyers compare it with marketplaces for the same jobs: quoting from a file, one supplier, prototype through production.
- Why isn't the price in the table?
- Marketplace prices are generated per part and change with geometry, material, quantity and date, and none of the five homepages publishes a price list. Our own fees are not published here either. Get quotes on your part at your quantities and compare them at the same quantities.
Weighing a marketplace against direct shops?
Related pages
- CNC machining sourcingProduction-run CNC machining quotes with Allied Mile: which drawing details move the price, what to send a shop, and quotes compared at the same quantities.
- Custom parts sourcingCustom parts sourcing from drawings: what each shop needs in the drawing package to quote, what its quote is made of, and how Allied Mile runs the RFQs.
- Sourcing for hardware startupsSourcing for hardware startups with Allied Mile: what to buy and how to quote it at prototype, pilot and production, and what suppliers need from a small team.