CNC machining sourcing: production-run quotes you can compare
CNC (computer numerical control) machining sourcing for production runs starts with one RFQ (request for quote) fixing the revision, quantities, material, finish and inspection every shop prices. Allied Mile finds and vets shops, you approve the list, and the quotes arrive side by side.
What does a production CNC quote comparison look like?
A production CNC quote comparison shows each shop's unit price at the same quantities, with lead time and whatever the price leaves out beside it: the material cert, the FAI (first-article inspection) or the CoC (certificate of conformance). Here's an example: SHFT-0310 Rev A, a ground 416 stainless shaft, quoted by three turning shops at 100, 1,000 and 5,000 pieces. The Notes column is where the comparison is decided.
| Supplier | 100 pcs | 1,000 pcs | 5,000 pcs | Lead time | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Supplier A | $44.80 | $21.60 | $16.90 | 6 weeks | Cert, FAI and CoC included; grinds in-house |
| Supplier B | No quote below 500 pcs | $18.70 | $14.20 | 8 weeks | Cert included; FAI a separate $650 line |
| Supplier C | $41.20 | $23.40 | $19.80 | 4 weeks | No cert or inspection report priced; grinding sent out |
- All three shops quoted the same drawing, SHFT-0310 Rev A, with no fixture or tooling charge.
- Lead time is the shop's quoted time for the first production lot.
Supplier B is cheapest at 1,000 and 5,000 pieces even after its $650 FAI line is added, but it won't quote 100 pieces because its MOQ (minimum order quantity) is 500. Supplier C is cheapest and quickest at 100, but its price carries no cert or inspection report, so those are open questions before it can be compared with A. A quote comparison puts each gap next to the price instead of leaving it in a footnote on each quote.
What you send and what you get back
You send
- The drawing as PDF with its revision, plus the STEP or native CAD model
- Quantities to quote, the first order quantity and the annual volume
- Material spec and cert, finish, inspection reports and any certifications the shop must hold
You get back
- A supplier list of machine shops for you to approve before the RFQ goes out
- A quote comparison at each quantity, with cert and inspection inclusions noted beside the price
- Any shop's engineering question on your drawing, sent to you to answer
How does CNC sourcing work for a production run?
You send the drawing package
Send the drawing with its revision, the model, the quantities and the cert and inspection requirements. We sign your NDA (non-disclosure agreement) on request before you send drawings, and we agree how you'll send files on the call.
We check the package and flag gaps
We check the package for anything a shop will ask about before it quotes: a surface finish with no Ra (roughness average) value, a thread with no class of fit, a cert requirement that isn't on the print. You settle those before anything goes to a shop.
We find and vet machine shops
We look for shops in the U.S., Canada and Mexico that make this kind of part. Vetting means three checks: process and material fit, such as turning and grinding stainless; volume-range fit, meaning the shop already runs lots in the quantities you're quoting; and certificates reviewed when you require them.
You approve the supplier list
You see the list and approve it before any RFQ goes out. Add the shop that made your prototypes if you want its production price in the comparison, or strike one you'd rather not ask.
We run the RFQ
Every shop gets the same drawing, revision, quantities, cert and inspection requirements, and the same format to answer in. We collect the responses and follow up on gaps. If a shop asks an engineering question, such as whether a journal tolerance can open up, we send it to you.
You compare the quotes and choose a shop
You receive the quotes side by side at each quantity in the RFQ, each naming its shop, with anything a price leaves out noted. You choose, contact the shop and place the PO (purchase order) directly.
Which drawing details move a CNC price most?
Material, tolerance and surface finish move a CNC price most, followed by inspection paperwork and lot size. A machined price is mostly machine time plus material plus inspection, so every drawing detail that adds a pass, a second operation or a measurement adds to it. Specifying a detail where it matters, and leaving it general where it doesn't, is what keeps the price down without changing the part.
Here's an example of each detail, what it does to the price and how it could be specified for the SHFT-0310 shaft in the comparison above.
| Detail | Effect on price | What to specify (SHFT-0310 example) |
|---|---|---|
| Material and cert | Grade sets the stock cost and how fast it cuts. A material cert (mill test report) adds traceability work and can limit which bar the shop may buy. | 416 stainless bar, condition per drawing; material cert with every lot; no substitute grades |
| Tolerance class | Tighter tolerances mean slower cuts, more measuring and more scrap. Going from ±0.005 in to ±0.0003 in on a diameter can change the process, not only the time. | General ±0.005 in; two bearing journals ±0.0003 in; everything else general |
| Surface finish (Ra) | Ra below about 32 µin on a turned surface usually means grinding: a second operation and sometimes a second shop. | 16 µin Ra on the two journals; 63 µin Ra elsewhere |
| Threads and inserts | Each thread adds a tool and a gauge check. An insert adds a purchased part and a pressing step. | 3/8-24 UNF-2A thread on one end, gauged; no inserts |
| Deburr and edge break | 'Break all edges' is routine. A specified edge radius, or a no-burr requirement on a cosmetic surface, adds hand or tumble finishing. | Break edges 0.005–0.015 in; no burrs at the thread start |
| Inspection reports | FAI, a CoC and per-lot dimensional reports add inspection time. Some shops price them as a separate line, some include them. | FAI on the first lot; CoC and material cert with every shipment |
| Lot size and annual volume | Setup is spread across the lot, so 100 pieces cost far more each than 1,000. Annual volume lets a shop buy bar in quantity and price scheduled releases. | Quote 100 / 1,000 / 5,000 pcs; first order 1,000; annual volume stated; releases against a blanket order acceptable |
How do production quotes differ from marketplace instant quotes?
A marketplace's instant quote prices a model; a shop's production quote prices a drawing. Instant quoting reads your CAD file against the marketplace's own list of materials, finishes and tolerance options. A production quote comes from a machine shop whose estimator reads your drawing and prices the cert, the journal tolerances, the grinding, the inspection reports and the lot size, then quotes lead time, MOQ and terms under the shop's own name. Neither is wrong; they price different things, and manufacturing marketplace vs direct sourcing compares the two routes.
What to send a CNC shop to get a quote that holds
A quote holds when the shop priced the same part you'll order, so send everything an estimator would otherwise assume. Missing details come back as each shop's default, and every shop's default is different, which is how three quotes on one shaft end up not comparable.
This is the machining version of the package any made-to-print part needs. If the shaft is one line of a larger assembly, send the whole BOM (bill of materials): BOM sourcing sorts every line and sends each made-to-print part to the kind of shop that makes it, so the shaft goes to turning shops while the bracket next to it goes to a sheet metal shop.
- The drawing as PDF with the revision on it, plus the STEP or native CAD model. Shops price the drawing; the model saves programming time but usually carries no tolerances.
- The seven details in the table above, specified the way the SHFT-0310 column shows: where a detail matters, say so; where it doesn't, leave it to the general note. Add GD&T (geometric dimensioning and tolerancing) where a datum matters.
- A request that fixtures and inspection paperwork be quoted as separate lines, so unit prices line up across shops.
- The commercial fields every RFQ needs, delivery location, first-lot date and quote validity among them, are in the RFQ checklist.
Requirements and limitations
- Shops set their own prices, lead times, MOQs and quote validity. A quote matches the drawing revision, material and quantities it was priced from; change any of them and that line needs a new quote.
- Vetting narrows the field. It doesn't replace your own qualification: the FAI, incoming inspection and the cert requirement go in your PO with the shop you choose.
Questions buyers ask
- Can a shop quote from a STEP model alone?
- It can, but only against its own default tolerance, finish and inspection assumptions, so quotes from different shops won't line up. If you have no drawing, tell us which features are critical and what finish they need, and that goes into the RFQ as a note every shop prices.
- Why quote 5,000 pieces if our first order is 1,000?
- The 5,000-piece price shows the curve. If it's far below the 1,000-piece price, a blanket order with scheduled releases may be worth asking about; if it's close, the shop is already efficient at 1,000 and you can stop there. Say in the RFQ which quantity is the real first order, so no shop plans its capacity around the wrong one.
- Should the material cert and FAI be in the piece price or quoted separately?
- Either, as long as every shop does the same. Ask for them as separate lines in the RFQ so unit prices line up; the comparison then notes where a shop included them anyway, as Supplier A did in the example above.
- Our prototype shop did good work. Why ask anyone else for the production price?
- Keep it on the list; its quote belongs in the comparison. Many prototype shops price 1,000-piece lots high or decline them, because their machines and schedule are set up for short runs. The comparison shows where your shop lands against shops that run production lots.
Have machined parts going to production?
Related pages
- Custom parts sourcingCustom parts sourcing from drawings: what each shop needs in the drawing package to quote, what its quote is made of, and how Allied Mile runs the RFQs.
- Marketplace vs direct sourcingXometry, Fictiv, Protolabs Network, Fathom and Jiga vs buying direct from shops, alone or with Allied Mile: who you deal with, BOM handling, MOQs, tooling.
- Supplier quote comparisonQuotes arrive in different formats. Allied Mile sets the RFQ so they line up, then compares price per quantity, tooling, lead time, MOQ, validity and terms.