Manufacturing RFQ checklist: what to send so quotes come back comparable
An RFQ (request for quote) gets comparable quotes when every shop receives the same part number, revision, drawing, material, finish, quantity breaks and response format. Allied Mile's checklist and template cover each item, whether you run the RFQ or we do.
Download
What the RFQ template asks for
The template has one row per RFQ line, with the columns in three groups. Five header columns describe the RFQ as a whole and repeat on every row, so a line still makes sense when a shop quotes only part of the request. Seventeen line columns describe each part and the terms you want quoted. The last nine are the response block: leave them blank and ask each shop to fill them in per line. The line columns follow our BOM template, so a quote-ready BOM (bill of materials) line already supplies most of a row. The example row follows one formed steel bracket, BRKT-1042 Rev C, used 2 per assembly on 250 assemblies a year.
| Column | Required | Example | Why it matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| RFQ number | Yes | RFQ-2026-014 | Ties every response, question and revision notice to one request. Put it in each file name and in the email subject. |
| Issue date | Yes | 2026-11-16 | Fixes which drawing revision was current when the request went out, and starts the clock on the due date. |
| Due date | Yes | 2026-12-01 | Shops plan quoting time around it. Without one, responses arrive over weeks and you end up comparing quotes of different ages. |
| Buyer contact | Yes | Purchasing lead, buyer@yourcompany.example, +1 555 010 0100 | Commercial questions, extensions and the quote itself go to one named person, so nothing waits in a shared inbox. |
| Engineering contact | Yes | Design engineer for BRKT-1042, eng@yourcompany.example | A tolerance question that reaches an engineer on the first try gets answered before the due date, not after two forwards. |
| Line | Yes | 10 | Numbers each part within the RFQ, so a shop can quote some lines and decline others without ambiguity. |
| Part number | Yes | BRKT-1042 | The identifier every response must carry back. A quote without it can't be lined up against the others. |
| Revision | Yes | Rev C | Shops quote the revision they are given. State it on the line and in the drawing file name so the two can't drift apart. |
| Description | Yes | Formed steel bracket, 14 ga, powder coated | Lets a shop see whether the part fits its process before it opens the drawing, and lets you spot a mismatched file. |
| Quantity breaks | Yes | 250 / 500 / 1,000 pcs | Identical breaks for every shop make the quotes comparable. Include the quantity you will order and one break above it, to see where the price curve bends. |
| Annual volume | Yes | 500 pcs/yr (2 per assembly x 250 assemblies) | Shops size tooling and pricing on yearly volume, not on one order. Without it the breaks look like one-off lots. |
| Need dates | Yes | First articles by 2027-01-16; production by 2027-02-27 | A date the shop can't meet shows up as a higher price or a no-quote. Better to learn that in the quote than after the PO. |
| Material / grade | Yes | Cold-rolled steel, 14 ga, ASTM A1008; no substitutes | Decides which shops can quote and stops one shop pricing a cheaper grade than the others. Say whether substitutes are allowed, and which. |
| Finish | Yes | Black powder coat per drawing note; unit price must include it | Coating usually goes to a separate finisher, so a unit price can silently leave it out. State the spec and whether the unit price has to include it. |
| Drawing or file reference | Yes | BRKT-1042_RevC.pdf; BRKT-1042_RevC.step | The PDF carries the tolerances and notes; the STEP file carries the geometry. Name both with the part number and revision. |
| Critical tolerances and inspection | Yes | Hole pattern ±0.010 in; FAI on first lot; CoC with each shipment | Inspection is work the shop prices. Ask for FAI (first-article inspection), a CoC (certificate of conformance) or material certs here, not after the PO (purchase order). Write 'none' if none. |
| Required certifications | If known | Material cert (mill test report) with each lot; ISO 9001 shop preferred | Certificates rule some shops out and add paperwork for the rest. Listing them here means no shop quotes a price that a later cert request will raise. |
| Quote validity requested | Yes | 60 days from due date | Sets how long you have to compare and decide. Left blank, each shop picks its own window and some quotes expire before you place the PO. |
| Tooling quoted separately? | Yes | Yes; state tooling cost and who owns it | Asks for tooling as its own number so you can see it, and for the owner so ownership can be set in the PO. |
| Payment terms | If known | Net 30 requested; deposit acceptable for tooling only | Stating the terms you expect stops a deposit or short net terms hiding inside a unit price, or at least puts them beside it. |
| Response format / exceptions | Yes | Fill in the nine response columns per line; mark exceptions and no-quotes on the line, with a reason | One format, with exceptions marked line by line, does most of the work of making quotes comparable before they arrive. |
| Notes | If known | Deburr all edges; mating hardware supplied by buyer | Anything a shop needs that isn't on the drawing or in another column. Keep it to facts a quote depends on. |
| Quoted unit price per break | Yes | Shop fills in: $ at 250 / $ at 500 / $ at 1,000, one currency | Prices at your breaks line up against the other shops' prices. A price at a break you didn't ask for can only be estimated beside them. |
| Quoted tooling and owner | Yes | Shop fills in: tooling $ and who owns it once paid for | Paid once. Folded into the unit price it makes a quote look cheaper than it is; ownership decides whether you can move the part later. |
| Quoted lead time | Yes | Shop fills in: first article and production, in weeks from PO | First-article time tells you when you can inspect; production time tells you when you can ship. Shops often quote only one. |
| Quoted MOQ | Yes | Shop fills in: minimum pieces per order, per line | A low unit price with an MOQ (minimum order quantity) above your order quantity is a price you can't buy at. |
| Quote valid until | Yes | Shop fills in: a date, not a number of days | Days counted from an unstated quote date are ambiguous. A date can be checked against the day you expect to place the PO. |
| Quoted payment terms | Yes | Shop fills in: net terms, any deposit, whether tooling is paid up front | A 50% deposit and Net 30 cost different amounts in cash. The comparison should show both, not bury one. |
| Exceptions or no-quote reason | Yes | Shop fills in: substituted grade, finish excluded, or 'no quote: outside our size envelope'; 'none' if none | A silent exception, such as a substituted grade or a finish left out, is how a cheap quote stays cheap. Marked on the line, it lands in the comparison. |
| Country of manufacture | Yes | Shop fills in: where the part is made, including subcontracted operations | Affects lead time, certification paperwork and duties. Ask here rather than discover it on the first shipment. |
| Certs and inspection included | Yes | Shop fills in: which certs, reports and inspections the price covers | A material cert and an FAI report add cost. A quote without them isn't lower; it covers less. |
RFQ checklist
Tick every item before the package goes out. Each one missing comes back as a question, an assumption or a no-quote. Items with no column in the template, such as ship-to address, packaging and NDA (non-disclosure agreement) status, go in the cover email. A missing revision or drawing reference is the kind of gap our BOM review flags before an RFQ goes out.
- RFQ number on the sheet, in every file name and in the email subject line
- Issue date and due date stated, with the same due date for every shop
- Buyer contact for commercial questions and an engineering contact for drawing questions
- Part number and revision on every line, matching the drawing title block
- Drawing file per line as PDF, plus a STEP file for the 3D geometry, both named with part number and revision
- Material spec and grade, and whether substitutes are allowed
- Finish or coating spec, and whether the unit price must include it
- Critical tolerances called out, with the inspection you require: FAI, CoC, material certs
- Quantities and price breaks, the same for every shop, including the quantity you will actually order
- Annual volume stated, so shops can size tooling and pricing
- Need dates: when you need first articles and when production must ship
- Delivery location and shipping terms: who arranges and pays for shipment, and from where
- Packaging requirements, if any: bagging, labeling, quantity per carton
- Quote validity requested, as days from the due date
- Tooling to be quoted separately, with ownership stated
- Payment terms you expect, or a note that the shop should propose them
- Required certifications for the shop and for each lot, listed rather than implied
- NDA status settled: whether the drawings need one, and with which shops it is in place before they go out
- Response deadline and format: the nine response columns filled in per line
- How to mark exceptions and no-quotes: on the line, with a reason
How to send an RFQ that gets comparable quotes
Send every shop the same package on the same day: the completed RFQ sheet and, for each line, the PDF drawing and STEP file it references. Freeze the revision first. If a drawing changes while quotes are open, every shop gets the new revision and a new due date, or the quotes stop describing the same part.
Put the quantity breaks, the quote validity, the tooling rule and the response format in the RFQ itself, not in follow-up emails. Shops quote what they are asked. A shop asked for 250, 500 and 1,000 pieces quotes all three; a shop asked for 'about 500' picks its own break, and its price can't be put beside the others.
The checklist can't make up for what a drawing doesn't say. A missing tolerance, finish spec or material grade becomes an assumption, and three shops will assume three different things. On machined parts the usual gaps are tolerance class, surface finish and thread callouts; CNC machining sourcing lists the fields that move a machining price. Fix the drawing or state the requirement on the RFQ line before sending.
What to ask each shop to send back
The nine response columns of the template, filled in per line: unit price at each break, tooling and its owner, lead time for first article and for production, MOQ, a valid-until date, payment terms, exceptions or a no-quote reason, country of manufacture, and the certs and inspection the price covers. Because they are columns on the sheet you sent, a shop can return the same file with the blanks filled.
The fields matter more than the format. A shop that answers all nine in a plain email is easier to compare than one that sends a polished PDF with no MOQ. Ask for exceptions on the line they affect rather than in a cover note, so they land in the comparison beside the price they change.
What if a shop has questions before the due date?
Answer, then send the answer to every shop quoting that line. If one shop learns a hole tolerance can open up and the others don't, the quotes are no longer for the same part. Date each clarification and keep it with the RFQ record.
Treat a proposed substitution the same way. A different grade, coating or thickness is an exception, to be quoted and marked as one, not quietly priced in. Decide before the due date whether you'd accept it, and if so tell every shop.
A no-quote is information. One shop declining a line usually means the part doesn't fit its equipment. Three declining means the drawing, the quantity or the material is the problem, and the line needs attention before it goes out again.
What happens when the quotes come back?
Put every response into the same columns at the same quantities, with tooling separated and exceptions noted. Comparing supplier quotes walks through that normalization and has a comparison sheet to download; its columns cover the same fields as the response block above, so a complete response copies in with little retyping.
If you would rather not run the RFQ yourself, BOM sourcing is the same work with us sending the RFQs and chasing the responses. We review your BOM, find and vet manufacturers in the U.S., Canada and Mexico, and you approve the supplier list before any RFQ goes out. We collect the responses and route engineering questions to you. Every quote names its supplier; you choose, contact them and place the PO.
Questions buyers ask
- How many shops should I send an RFQ to?
- Three to five per line. Fewer than three and you can't tell an outlier from the market; more than five and the time you saved goes into chasing responses. Pick shops that already make that kind of part at roughly your volume; a shop that fits the process but not the volume will quote high or decline.
- Is a PDF drawing enough, or do shops need a STEP file?
- A PDF drawing with the revision is the minimum for a made-to-print part; it carries the tolerances, material and finish notes a quote depends on. The STEP file saves the shop modeling time and avoids misread geometry. Send both when you have them, and say which governs if they disagree, usually the drawing.
- Should every part get its own RFQ?
- One RFQ with a line per part is easier to track, but group the lines by process. A sheet metal shop shouldn't receive turned shafts, and a machine shop shouldn't be asked to quote a molded gasket. Each shop quotes the lines it makes and marks the rest no-quote.
Want help running the RFQ?
Related pages
- Supplier quote comparisonQuotes arrive in different formats. Allied Mile sets the RFQ so they line up, then compares price per quantity, tooling, lead time, MOQ, validity and terms.
- BOM templateDownload Allied Mile's manufacturing BOM template (Excel or CSV): 17 columns, a filled example line, and which fields a supplier needs before it can quote.
- BOM sourcingBOM sourcing with Allied Mile: we sort every line, find and vet manufacturers for your custom parts, run the RFQs and line up the quotes side by side.