Second source suppliers: from a single-source part to dual sourcing

Qualify a second source with one RFQ (request for quote) package sent to candidates, a comparison against the incumbent's price, tooling and lead time, and a first-article run. Allied Mile finds and vets candidates; you approve the list and place the PO (purchase order).

What does a second-source comparison look like?

The incumbent is the first row, at the price, tooling position and lead time you have today. Candidates quote the same drawing at the same quantity, with tooling as a separate line and first-article inspection (FAI) as a quoted item, in the same columns as any quote comparison. Here's an example: GSKT-2208, a molded silicone gasket bought from one supplier for years, quoted at 5,000 pieces a year.

Units: Unit prices in USD at 5,000 pcs; tooling as a one-time chargeExample — illustrative data
SupplierUnit priceToolingLead timeFirst articlesNotes
Supplier A (incumbent)$1.42Existing single-cavity mold, owned by you5 weeksNone; parts approvedBaseline: your only source today.
Supplier B$1.26Transfer: $750 to receive, inspect and sample your mold4 weeks after the mold arrives30 pcs; FAI charge quoted separatelyReplacement, not a parallel source: your mold leaves A.
Supplier C$1.09New: $4,800 single-cavity mold, owned by you10 weeks first run, then 530 pcs; FAI charge quoted separatelyParallel source; mold repaid after about 14,500 pcs.

Year one at 5,000 pieces, before FAI charges: Supplier A $7,100; Supplier B $7,050 including the transfer charge; Supplier C $10,250 including the new mold. All figures are invented for illustration.

What you send and what you get back

You send

  • The part's drawing at its current revision, with material and finish specs
  • The incumbent's current unit price, lead time and terms, and the tooling paperwork from the original PO
  • Annual quantity, the price breaks you want quoted, and the first-article sample quantity you require
  • Why you want a second source: line-stop risk, capacity, a price check, or all three

You get back

  • A comparison that sets every candidate quote, each naming its supplier, against the incumbent's current price, tooling and lead time
  • Tooling quoted as a separate line, marked new or transfer, with ownership stated
  • First-article inspection quoted as its own item at your sample quantity
  • Open questions on anything in the drawing a new supplier can't quote as drawn

How does qualifying a second source work?

  1. You set the baseline

    Tell us the part, the incumbent's current unit price, lead time and payment terms, who owns the tooling, and how long the incumbent has made it. Tell us why you want a second source, too: a line-stop risk, a capacity limit or a price check. The reason sets what a candidate has to beat.

  2. We check the RFQ package

    We review the drawing at its current revision, the material and finish specs, the quantities and the inspection requirements, and flag anything a new supplier would ask about. After years with one supplier, the drawing often lags what ships: a tolerance opened by email, a compound changed by phone. Those go to you as open questions before anything is sent.

  3. We find and vet candidates; you approve the list

    We find manufacturers in the U.S., Canada and Mexico that run the same process and material at your volume, and review certificates when you require them. You see the supplier list and approve it before any RFQ goes out, and you decide whether the incumbent re-quotes the same package or stays as the baseline at today's price.

  4. We send the same RFQ to every candidate

    Every candidate gets the same drawing, revision, quantities, material and finish. The RFQ asks for tooling as a separate line, states whether your existing tooling can transfer, and asks for FAI as a quoted item at your sample quantity. Engineering questions from a candidate, such as a draft angle its mold can't hold, are routed to you.

  5. You choose who gets a first-article order

    You receive the comparison, every candidate quote naming its supplier. You choose which candidate, if any, gets a first-article PO, place it with the supplier directly, and inspect the first articles against the drawing.

How does a second-source RFQ treat the incumbent?

The incumbent is the baseline, not a candidate. Its current price, lead time, terms and tooling position go into the first row of the comparison as they stand, so every candidate quote is measured against what you pay today rather than against the other candidates.

Candidates get one RFQ package: the drawing at the current revision, material and finish, your annual quantity and the breaks you want, inspection and certificate requirements, and a plain statement of the tooling situation. If the drawing has drifted from what the incumbent ships, those gaps go to you as open questions and you settle them before the package goes out, because a candidate that quotes the drawing will make the drawing.

The responses go into the same columns as the incumbent's row, at the same quantity, with tooling separate and exclusions noted. It is the same normalization as any quote comparison; the only difference is that one row was never quoted.

Second source or dual sourcing: which do you need?

A second source is a backup: a supplier that has passed your FAI and can take the part at short notice. Dual sourcing is two suppliers running live volume, so both stay current on the revision and neither forgets how to make the part.

The first needs a quote, a tooling position and one FAI run. The second needs tooling at both suppliers and a volume split you can sustain. In the GSKT-2208 example, only Supplier C's new mold allows dual sourcing; Supplier B's transfer qualifies a replacement, not a parallel source, because your mold leaves the incumbent.

Who owns the tooling, and can it move?

Whoever paid for the tooling as a separate line usually owns it; whoever absorbed it into the piece price usually doesn't. Start with the original PO and the incumbent's quote. If tooling appeared as its own line and you paid it, you can normally ask for the tool, its drawings and its maintenance record. If the incumbent built the tool at its own cost and recovered it in the unit price, the tool is probably theirs, and a second source means a new tool.

Owning a tool and moving it are different things. A mold or die that moves needs the receiving supplier to inspect it, fit it to its press and sample it, which is the transfer charge in Supplier B's row. Some suppliers decline to run another supplier's tool at all.

While the tool is at the new supplier, the incumbent cannot make the part. For dual sourcing on a molded or cast part, budget for a second tool, as Supplier C quoted.

Machined and sheet metal parts are different. Their tooling is usually fixtures, programs and press-brake setups that each shop builds for itself at modest cost, so a second source is mostly an FAI and a capacity question. How tooling changes which quote is cheapest covers the general case; for machined parts, see production-run CNC quotes.

When is a second source not worth it?

When the part cannot stop your line and the tooling cost outweighs years of savings. In the GSKT-2208 example, a new mold at Supplier C saves $0.33 a piece and costs $4,800, so it pays back after about 14,500 pieces: nearly three years at 5,000 a year. On price alone that is a poor trade. It is worth it if a late gasket shipment stops assemblies, or if the incumbent is at capacity or at risk.

If the risk doesn't justify an FAI run yet, a middle path is to run the RFQ and stop there. You learn who else can make the part and what it would cost, and you keep the comparison on file, so a supplier failure becomes a phone call rather than a search. Fund the FAI run when the risk justifies it.

Three other cases call for holding off, each with a cheaper hedge than a second source:

  • The part is being redesigned and the revision will change within the year. Hold safety stock through the change and quote candidates at the new revision.
  • The incumbent runs a proprietary compound or process no candidate can match to the drawing. Get the compound or process onto the drawing as a specification a supplier can quote to; until then, treat the part as single-source and hold stock.
  • Annual spend is so small that an FAI run costs more than a year of parts. Settle the tooling position in writing with the incumbent, get the tool drawings, and hold safety stock.

Requirements and limitations

  • A quote is not a qualified source. Until a candidate's first articles pass your inspection, the incumbent is still your only supplier, whatever the second quote says.
  • We don't settle tooling ownership. If your original PO and the incumbent's terms are silent, that conversation is between you and the incumbent before the RFQ goes out.
  • Candidate quotes carry their own validity dates. If you run the RFQ now and fund the FAI run later, expect to confirm or refresh the quotes first.

Questions buyers ask

Should we tell the incumbent we're quoting a second source?
That is your decision, and you make it when you approve the supplier list. Many buyers do say so: a second source is normal practice for any part that can stop a line, and the incumbent may sharpen its own quote. If you would rather not, leave the incumbent off the list; its current price still anchors the comparison.
What should the first-article inspection cover?
The drawing's critical dimensions, the material certificate, the finish, and anything the incumbent's parts do that the drawing doesn't say, such as how a gasket seats in its groove. Ask the candidate for its inspection report with the first articles, inspect against the drawing yourself or through a lab you choose, and fit-check in the assembly. Approve in writing so the candidate's revision and your approval match.
Do we need the incumbent's cooperation to move the tool?
In practice, yes. The incumbent holds the tool, its drawings and its maintenance record, and your PO terms set what it must release. Plan the handover at a natural break: after a production run, with safety stock on hand and the incumbent's open invoices settled, because a tool rarely ships while a dispute is open.
Is a second source for a catalog part the same job?
No. For a catalog part, such as a connector or a bearing, the second source is an approved alternate with its own manufacturer part number (MPN), plus stock at a second distributor. That is a BOM (bill of materials) change and a qualification, not an RFQ. This page is about made-to-print parts with one supplier.

Have a part with only one supplier?