Choosing a sourcing partner for custom parts: ten questions to ask
Choose a sourcing partner for custom parts by asking ten questions on the first call, starting with whether every quote names the supplier and who places the purchase orders. Here is each question, what a good answer looks like, and how Allied Mile answers it.
Download
Questions to bring to the first call
Put these ten questions to any sourcing partner or sourcing agent, including us, and write the answers down in the same order, so you compare partners on answers rather than on sales calls. Still deciding whether to hand the whole assembly to a contract manufacturer instead? Start with sourcing agent vs contract manufacturer.
- Will every quote name the supplier, and can I contact that shop directly? (Good answer: yes, with nothing in the agreement stopping me.)
- Who places the purchase orders (POs): you or me? (Good answer: I do, with each supplier I choose.)
- How are you paid, and does it change with order value? (Good answer: a plain statement of who pays and what the fee is tied to.)
- Will you sign our non-disclosure agreement (NDA) before we send drawings? (Good answer: yes, before any drawing is sent.)
- What do you check before a supplier goes on my list, and what don't you check? (Good answer: a short, specific list of each, and I approve the list before anything goes to suppliers.)
- Can I send part of the bill of materials (BOM), or does it have to be the full one? (Good answer: partial is fine; the full BOM gets a line-by-line review.)
- When a shop has an engineering question about my drawing, who answers it? (Good answer: I do, and the question reaches me as the shop asked it.)
- What do you do with catalog lines, such as fasteners and bearings? (Good answer: identify them and recommend where to buy; no quoting or buying them.)
- What happens to the quotes when a revision changes one part? (Good answer: only the changed line goes back out; the rest stand while valid.)
- If we stop working together, what do I keep: supplier names, quotes, tooling? (Good answer: all three, with no restriction on contacting the suppliers.)
1. Will every quote name the supplier?
A good answer: yes, every quote names the manufacturer, you can contact that shop directly, and nothing in the agreement stops you from working with it later. A partner that will only name the supplier after you commit, or quotes under a blanket label such as 'a partner shop', is asking you to accept a margin you can't see.
Ask this first, because it decides whether you own the supplier relationships or rent them. Some sourcing partners pass quotes through under their own name, so you never learn which shop makes your part. That works until you need to move the part, visit the shop or qualify a second source, and then you are starting from zero.
2. Who places the purchase orders?
A good answer: you place each PO directly with the supplier you choose, on your terms, and the partner's job ends at the quote comparison. There can be reasons for a partner to buy on your behalf, such as combining small orders to clear an MOQ (minimum order quantity), but you should hear a reason, not a default.
Whoever places the PO is the supplier's customer. If the partner places POs, the shop works for the partner: invoices, warranty, quality claims and tooling all run through a company you don't control. If you place them, the shop is your supplier and the paperwork says so.
3. How is the partner paid, and does it change with order value?
A good answer: a plain statement of who pays, what the fee is tied to, and whether any supplier pays the partner anything. If the answer is vague, ask the suppliers on the quotes whether they pay a commission. For how a partner's cost compares with a buyer on your payroll, see hiring a buyer vs a sourcing partner.
Ask how the partner earns money before you ask how much, because the structure shapes the advice. A percentage of order value rewards a higher PO. A commission paid by the supplier rewards whichever shop pays it. A fixed project fee or an hourly rate keeps the partner neutral between quotes, but you carry the cost whether or not a usable quote comes back.
4. Will the partner sign your NDA before you send drawings?
A good answer: yes, on your paper or theirs, before any drawing is sent. Then ask who at the suppliers will see the drawing and what they will see: the full title block, or a version with your company name removed. A partner should be able to tell you both.
Your drawings carry tolerances, materials and design intent that a competitor could use. An NDA with the partner covers only the first hand-off; what happens after that depends on how the partner passes files to suppliers, which is why the second question matters.
5. What does the partner check before a supplier goes on your list?
A good answer: a short, specific list of what is checked, and an equally specific list of what is not. Treat the checks as a filter, not a qualification: a first-article inspection (FAI) is still yours to run, so be wary of a partner who says you can skip it. For how the fit checks narrow a long list of shops to a few, see how to find manufacturers that fit your part.
Vetting means different things to different partners, from a phone call to a site audit, so ask for the list of checks rather than accepting the word. The checks that matter for a quote are whether the shop runs the process and material your part needs, whether it works at your volume, and whether it holds the certifications you require. Then ask whether you see and approve the supplier list before any request for quote (RFQ) goes out.
6. Can you send part of the BOM?
A good answer: a partial BOM is fine, and the partner can say what seeing the full one would change: which lines it would send to distribution rather than out for quotes, and which would come back as no-quotes as sent. Watch for a full-BOM requirement with no reason attached beyond 'that's how we work'. For what a line-by-line review covers, see BOM sourcing.
You may only want help with the hard lines: the casting nobody will quote, or the machined housing with three no-quotes behind it. Some partners want the whole BOM because their fee follows the spend, so ask whether a partial BOM is accepted, and what changes if you send the full one.
7. When a shop has an engineering question, who answers it?
A good answer: engineering questions come to you, in the supplier's own words, and your answer goes back to the supplier. The partner can collect and sort the questions, but it shouldn't decide them. Ask how a question reaches you and who sees your answer.
Suppliers ask questions while quoting: a tolerance they can't hold, a material they'd substitute, an inside radius the tool can't reach. Someone has to answer, and the answer changes the part. If the partner answers for you, you may get a quote on a part you didn't design.
8. What does the partner do with catalog lines?
A good answer: catalog lines are identified and you get a recommendation on where to buy them, while the partner's effort goes to the made-to-print lines, where asking different shops changes the price. If the partner wants to buy catalog parts for you, ask what that costs and why.
A BOM for a custom assembly carries a long tail of catalog lines: fasteners, bearings, connectors and off-the-shelf hardware with published prices and stock you can check, so they rarely need an RFQ. A partner that quotes or buys them anyway adds a step, and possibly a margin, to parts you could order from a distributor this afternoon.
9. What happens to the quotes when a revision changes one part?
A good answer: only the lines a revision touches go back out, at the new revision; the other quotes stand while their validity lasts; and the partner tells you up front what a change costs. Ask, too, how revisions are tracked, so no shop quotes Rev B after you have moved to Rev C. Watch for 'we re-quote everything', or a partner that can't say what a change costs until it happens.
Designs change during sourcing, especially before the first production run. A quote is tied to the drawing revision it was made against, so a change to one part means a new quote for that part. The question is what happens to everything else, and whether a change costs you a new round of fees.
10. If you stop working together, what do you keep?
A good answer: you keep the supplier names and contacts, every quote and comparison, and the tooling you paid for, which should be named as yours in your PO with the shop that built it. Watch for a non-circumvention clause that bars you from contacting the suppliers after you part ways; if there is one, get its scope in writing.
Exit is the question buyers forget to ask until they need it. If the partner holds the supplier names, the POs and the tooling, leaving means re-sourcing the BOM from the start. If you hold them, leaving means not booking the next call.
How Allied Mile answers these
Our answers to the ten questions, in the same order.
- Supplier disclosure: every quote names its supplier, and you contact that shop directly.
- Purchase orders: you place every PO with the supplier you choose.
- Fees: not published.
- NDA: we sign yours on request, before you send drawings. We agree how you'll send files on the call.
- Checks: three. Process and material fit, volume-range fit, and certificates reviewed when you require them. You see and approve the supplier list before any RFQ goes out.
- Partial BOMs: accepted. The full BOM is more useful.
- Engineering questions: a supplier's question about your drawing is routed to you to answer.
- Catalog lines: you get a distribution recommendation; we don't buy them.
- Revisions: a changed line goes back out at its new revision; the other lines keep their quotes while those quotes are valid.
- Exit: you hold every supplier name, every quote and every PO, so there is nothing to hand back. Tooling is agreed in your PO with the shop that builds it.
Questions buyers ask
- Should I ask a contract manufacturer the same questions?
- Most of them. A contract manufacturer usually won't name its part suppliers or break out per-part prices; that is the trade for one price and one point of contact. The questions on fees, the NDA, revisions and exit apply unchanged, and the exit question matters more, because tooling inside an assembly price may stay with the contract manufacturer or its supplier unless your contract says otherwise.
- How many sourcing partners should I talk to?
- Two or three. Fewer, and you can't tell a market norm from one partner's policy; more, and the calls start to cost more than the decision. A partner that won't answer one of the ten has answered it.
- Do I need to share drawings to get these questions answered?
- No. None of the ten needs a drawing, and a partner's answers should be the same whether your part is a bracket or a housing. Send drawings after the NDA is signed, if you want one, and after you have heard answers you like.
Want to put these questions to us?
Related pages
- Sourcing agent vs contract manufacturerHand the assembly to a contract manufacturer, or source the parts with a partner like Allied Mile? Compare cost visibility, tooling and who places the POs.
- Hiring a buyer vs sourcing partnerHire a buyer, keep sourcing with the founder, or work with a sourcing partner like Allied Mile? Compare time to start, cost structure and continuity.
- Find a manufacturerHow Allied Mile finds a manufacturer for your part: narrowing by process, material, size, volume and certifications, and what vetting does and doesn't check.